50 First Dates the Musical
The Other Palace
Walking into the world premiere of 50 First Dates: The Musical, I didn’t really know what to expect. I haven’t seen the original film, so I came in with fresh eyes and no preconceptions. What I got was a fun, heartwarming tale full of laugh-out-loud comedy, sweet romance, and a cast that truly pours their energy into every moment. It’s not perfect, but it’s definitely a crowd-pleasing new addition to the musical theatre scene.
The story follows Lucy, played by Georgina Castle, who is utterly charming in the role. She brings warmth, humour, and vulnerability to a character who could easily feel one-note. Opposite her, Josh St Clair shines as Henry, balancing comic timing with a sincerity that makes their relationship believable. Together, they make a likeable pairing, grounding the show’s quirkiness with genuine chemistry.
For me, though, the standout was Chad St Louis as Sandy, a Disney-loving character who lights up the stage every time he appears. His vocals are sublime, soaring, effortless, and memorable; and his comic flair makes him the kind of scene-stealer audiences will talk about afterwards. Natasha O’Brien is also perfectly cast as Delilah; she’s hilarious, bold, and brings a spark of chaos that keeps the momentum rolling. The rest of the ensemble is equally strong, with every performer pulling their weight to create a show that feels tightly knit and well-rehearsed.
At just one act and around 100 minutes, the show is lean and well-paced, managing to pack in both big laughs and tender moments. However, the ending does feel a little rushed, as if the creative team were racing to tie everything together before the curtain falls. Another ten minutes of breathing space might have allowed the conclusion to land with more emotional weight.
The music is fun and infectious in the moment, and the cast performs it with absolute gusto. The problem is that, like Lucy’s forgetful condition, none of the songs really stick in your head after you leave the theatre. They’re enjoyable while you’re watching, but there aren’t any standout motifs or melodies that elevate the show into instant-classic territory. A stronger, more memorable score would take 50 First Dates from enjoyable to unmissable.
Visually, the production is bright and colourful, with clever set design that helps transport the audience into its tropical, playful world without overcomplicating things. The choreography is light, cheeky, and matches the tone of the show, keeping things lively throughout.
In the end, 50 First Dates: The Musical is exactly what you’d want from a rom-com on stage: it’s funny, heartwarming, and full of charm. The cast is excellent, the pacing is snappy, and there’s a lot of joy to be had in watching it. It might not yet be destined for the status of a theatrical classic, but it’s certainly a promising and highly entertaining premiere.
★★★
Reviewed on Wednesday 24th September 2025 by Olivia
Photo Credit: Pamela Raith
{AD PR Invite- tickets gifted in exchange for honest review}
Keywords: 50 First Dates musical review, world premiere 50 First Dates stage show, Georgina Castle Lucy 50 First Dates, Josh St Clair Henry 50 First Dates, Chad St Louis Sandy Disney 50 First Dates, Natasha O’Brien Delilah 50 First Dates, new musicals 2025 review, rom-com musical UK premiere.
Comments